2,851
edits
Line 105: | Line 105: | ||
== Controversy about NMN as Direct Precursor == | == Controversy about NMN as Direct Precursor == | ||
NMN is often | NMN is often advertised, for example by NMN suppliers, as a direct precursor to NAD+, purportedly making it more effective compared to other precursors like '''Nicotinamide Riboside (NR)'''. However, NMN's role as a direct precursor is only effective when it is '''inside the cell'''. This raises questions about how NMN, when ingested or administered externally, enters the cell to contribute to NAD+ synthesis. The central controversy surrounding NMN as a precursor to NAD+ lies in its mechanism of cellular entry. While NMN is a direct precursor of NAD+ within the cell, the debate focuses on whether NMN can be directly absorbed by cells or if it must first be converted to NR. In that case, NR might have an advantage over NMN, as NMN would require one additional conversion step compared to NR. | ||
=== Direct Transport Mechanism === | === Direct Transport Mechanism === | ||
One hypothesis | One hypothesis suggests that NMN can directly enter cells through specific transporters. The ''Slc12a8'' transporter in the aged mouse ileum has been suggested to facilitate NMN's direct absorption{{pmid|31131364}}. However, this idea has faced challenges due to conflicting research findings{{pmid|32694648}}{{pmid|27725675}}, and the functionality of ''Slc12a8'' in humans has yet to be conclusively determined. | ||
=== Dephosphorylation to NR as a Precursor === | === Dephosphorylation to NR as a Precursor === | ||
An alternative and currently more widely accepted theory proposes that NMN is not directly | An alternative and currently more widely accepted theory proposes that NMN is not directly utilized by cells. Instead, it is first converted to '''Nicotinamide Riboside (NR)''' through dephosphorylation before cellular absorption. This conversion is mediated by enzymes like CD73. Once inside the cell as NR, it is then phosphorylated into NMN{{pmid|27725675}}{{pmid|32389638}}. Studies, such as those by Kim et al., indicate that orally ingested NMN is predominantly converted to NR in the intestinal tissue before absorption, challenging the view of NMN as a direct precursor to NAD+{{pmid|37463842}}. | ||
==Potential Benefits== | ==Potential Benefits== |