2,851
edits
(Created page with "* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9IxomBusuw&ab_channel=AndrewHuberman * Interviewer: Andrew Huberman * Length: 2:10:42 * In this interview, we discuss the cellular and molec...") |
|||
Line 4,516: | Line 4,516: | ||
and the resveratrol altogether. | and the resveratrol altogether. | ||
And there's a good reason for that. | |||
It's all scientific, I try to be. | |||
The levels of NAD go up in the morning | |||
in our bodies naturally. | |||
Our bodies actually have a | |||
cycle of NAD, it's not steady. | |||
- It's Arcadian? | |||
- It's Acadian. | |||
In fact, NAD controls your clock. | |||
This was shown by Shin Imai and colleagues | |||
in this nice science | |||
paper about a decade ago, | |||
that if you disrupt the NAD cycle, | |||
which is controlled by the | |||
sirtuin gene that we worked on, | |||
that is what's telling your | |||
body, oh, it's time to eat, | |||
it's time to go to sleep. | |||
And if you take these, the NMN | |||
late at night, for example, | |||
you can disrupt your circadian rhythms. | |||
- Interesting. | |||
- Conversely, when I travel | |||
and I want to reset my clock | |||
to the time zone, I will take | |||
a boost of NMN in the morning | |||
and I feel great. | |||
- Does this protocol for you, | |||
does it produce any immediate effects | |||
of increased energy, et cetera? | |||
You mentioned that one would, | |||
if it's right for them, | |||
would have to take it | |||
for at least two weeks | |||
to start to see the NAD levels increase. | |||
At that point, when NAD levels increase, | |||
could one possibly expect an increase | |||
in overall energy, focus, et cetera? | |||
I realize we're not making promises here, | |||
but I'm just wondering whether | |||
or not the only measure | |||
of whether or not this protocol is working | |||
is whether or not you die at | |||
age blank or blank plus 20. | |||
And of course, once you're dead, | |||
you can't really know if | |||
you would've lived longer | |||
if you'd done something | |||
differently and vice versa. | |||
- Sure, well, there was a | |||
study again by Shin Imai | |||
my good friend at Washington | |||
University in St. Louis | |||
that showed that improves, | |||
remember this insulin sensitivity, | |||
which is a good thing. | |||
But you can't know your | |||
insulin sensitivity | |||
unless you're measuring glucose, | |||
have a glucose monitor on your arm. | |||
- Do you have one on right now? | |||
- No, no, I used to, I learned a lot. | |||
- Yeah, last time I | |||
saw you had this thing, | |||
it looks like a small leach, | |||
not a large leach and it was | |||
measuring your blood glucose. | |||
- They're very informative | |||
because you learn | |||
what your body reacts to | |||
and grapes were really bad. | |||
Rhonda Patrick agrees with | |||
that, but the issue was, | |||
was what, where were we, Andrew? | |||
- The issue is whether | |||
or not you can expect | |||
any immediate effects on | |||
energy, vitality, focus, | |||
just even subject. | |||
- So what do you feel, is the question. | |||
And anecdotally, | |||
'cause I've been taking | |||
this for a long time, | |||
if I don't take it, I | |||
start to feel 50 years old, | |||
it's horrible. | |||
I can't think straight. | |||
It may be placebo, but who knows? | |||
But what we're doing now are | |||
very careful clinical trials. | |||
We've done the safety for two years, | |||
and we're now treating elderly patients | |||
at Harvard Medical School with | |||
some wonderful colleagues. | |||
And those people are actually going | |||
to be an currently in MRIs. | |||
So you can measure the | |||
energetics and the NAD levels | |||
in their legs as they | |||
exercise in real time. | |||
And that will tell us if | |||
what we see in the mice | |||
is increased endurance actually works. | |||
In the meantime, it's fun | |||
to talk about anecdotes. | |||
I have a number of athlete friends, | |||
some of which have increased their load, | |||
their time in marathons, for example. | |||
There's a good friend | |||
of ours in our circle | |||
that is winning marathons at age 50 now. | |||
And he attributes that to | |||
the protocol that he's on. | |||
- Interesting, I haven't | |||
started taking NMN, | |||
but I'm planning to do that | |||
when my next birthday arrives, | |||
which is in a couple months. | |||
But I do experiments on my | |||
sister and have for years, | |||
I have a sister who's three | |||
years older than I am, | |||
who is very enthusiastic | |||
about these protocols. | |||
And I'll tell you that | |||
after reading your book, | |||
I started purchasing | |||
for her and giving her | |||
an NMN supplement and she | |||
claims and I believe her. | |||
She has a quite sensitive system | |||
and she's very tuned into it. | |||
She feels far and away | |||
better when she takes it, | |||
as opposed to when she doesn't | |||
and I've done the control | |||
experiment of removing her supply, | |||
and then giving it back to | |||
her in this kind of thing. | |||
So that's my other laboratory. | |||
This is what younger brothers | |||
do to their older sisters. | |||
I have a question about something | |||
that if it has no relevance, | |||
we can just treat it as a speed | |||
bump and then move right on. | |||
And the artificial sweeteners, | |||
these things that we | |||
should say non-glucose, | |||
increasing sweetener. | |||
So you've got Stevia, | |||
which is a plant basically. | |||
And then you've got | |||
sucralose and aspartame | |||
and all these things. | |||
There is some evidence that | |||
I know we're both aware of, | |||
they've been publishing | |||
quite reputable journals, | |||
showing that they can | |||
disrupt the gut microbiome | |||
in certain cases in particular saccharin, | |||
the one that basically | |||
nobody uses anymore. | |||
And it's questionable as | |||
to whether or not Stevia | |||
has the same negative effects, et cetera. | |||
That's not what this is about, | |||
but in terms of the sensation of, | |||
or the perception of sweet taste, | |||
is that itself a possible detriment | |||
to these pro-longevity, | |||
forgive me for using the term, | |||
the pathways. | |||
If I were to drink a | |||
diet coke during a fast, | |||
am I somehow disrupting this? | |||
And I'm asking this question, | |||
because I get asked this question a lot. | |||
- Well, there may be small effects. | |||
I don't think they're | |||
worth worrying about. | |||
Joe Rogan laughed at me 'cause | |||
I was drinking a diet coke | |||
during the first | |||
interview I did with them. | |||
I will drink diet coke, I've | |||
read the scientific literature. | |||
And again, it's this 5% thing | |||
that I think is blowing out of proportion. | |||
If I was to put a number | |||
on it, I would say, | |||
if eating a high sugary meal | |||
or drinking a sugar-filled soda, | |||
what is that, 30 grams of sugar? | |||
Let's say that's a 10 | |||
out of 10 bad for you. | |||
A diet coke might be a one. | |||
And if I'm, which am I going to do? | |||
I could have a 10 or a one | |||
or go without in my life. | |||
I'll do the one on occasion. | |||
I try to avoid them because I | |||
don't like the ones as much. | |||
But you can't say that sucralose | |||
is equivalent to drinking a sugary soda. | |||
There's just no comparison. | |||
And I think suc, what is it? | |||
Stevia, I do use Stevia whenever I can, | |||
because it's a naturally sourced product. | |||
And I haven't seen any good evidence yet | |||
that it's bad for you. | |||
But I think a lot of this is overblown, | |||
and a lot of it's the media trying | |||
to give equal weight to stories | |||
as you know as a scientist. | |||
It can be frustrating | |||
when something's a 10 | |||
and something's a one, | |||
and they're equated. | |||
- How do I say this respectfully? | |||
I think if science | |||
journalists were required | |||
to post their credentials | |||
alongside their name, [chuckles] | |||
then people would take the articles into, | |||
with additional grain of salt, right? | |||
I mean, in other words, | |||
that I think that the science media | |||
is mainly generated | |||
around two specific goals. | |||
One is to make people very, very afraid | |||
or get people very, very excited, | |||
and oftentimes the get people excited part | |||
is sponsored content, | |||
and I think that's overlooked in any case. | |||
Thank you for that. | |||
I want to talk about iron and iron load. | |||
We were talking earlier about ferritin. | |||
And of course, women menstruate. | |||
And so their iron needs | |||
are greater than people, | |||
men that don't menstruate | |||
or women that don't menstruate. | |||
I don't think we can get right down | |||
into how much iron somebody needs | |||
because it'll vary person to person. | |||
But I was surprised to learn that iron | |||
is actually going to accelerate | |||
the aging process in various contexts. | |||
- Well, this is a new | |||
finding out of Spain. | |||
Manuel Serrano's lab has | |||
found that excess iron | |||
will increase the number of | |||
senescent cells in the body. | |||
And senescent cells are these zombie cells | |||
that accumulate as you get | |||
older and they sit there | |||
and they cause inflammation mainly | |||
and also can cause cancer. | |||
And it's found that if | |||
you get rid of these cells | |||
or never accumulate | |||
them, you stay younger. | |||
In animals, and there's some | |||
really interesting studies | |||
out of Mayo Clinic in humans as well. | |||
So iron is a pro-senescent metal. | |||
And so what I think | |||
is that if you're taking | |||
excess iron as a supplement, | |||
you're probably accelerating | |||
your aging process. | |||
The other thing that I | |||
found really interesting | |||
is I've looked at hundreds of thousands | |||
of people's metabolism and | |||
their blood biomarkers. | |||
I was one of the first people | |||
in InsideTracker as a board member, | |||
and I'm still their scientific lead guy. | |||
So I can look anonymously | |||
at hundreds of thousands | |||
of people's blood work. | |||
And we also know how fit | |||
they are, how old they are. | |||
Some of them are marathon runners, | |||
some of them are CrossFit. | |||
And there's a signature of health | |||
that actually is different | |||
than your average person. | |||
Now, I'm not going to | |||
say bad things about MDs | |||
'cause a lot of my best friends are MDs | |||
and I work with them at | |||
Harvard Medical School. | |||
The issue though, is | |||
that with MD training, | |||
there's a scale of what's normal, | |||
and if you're out of that normal range, | |||
something must be wrong, | |||
that's the paradigm that they work under. | |||
But first of all, everybody's different, | |||
and you want to know their baseline | |||
and track people over years to | |||
know what's normal for them. | |||
And what I find for example, | |||
is people who are really | |||
healthy and live the way I do | |||
and have a diet that's fairly | |||
vegetarian, but not strict, | |||
still have slightly low hemoglobin levels, | |||
slightly low iron, slightly low ferritin, | |||
but we have super amounts | |||
of energy, we're not anemic. | |||
And we're getting along great in life. | |||
But a doctor who just | |||
looks at that might say, | |||
oh, we need to give you more iron. | |||
All right, so what I'm | |||
getting at is an example of, | |||
we need to personalize medicine | |||
and look at people over the long run | |||
to know what works for them | |||
and what's healthy for them, | |||
and not just work towards | |||
the average human, | |||
but work towards what's optimal for human. | |||
- I love that answer. | |||
You mentioned tracking | |||
and tracking over time. | |||
And this is a really interesting area | |||
that I know you have been | |||
focused on for a long time. | |||
I've been getting blood worked | |||
on about every six months | |||
frankly, since I was in college. | |||
I just got, I like data | |||
and I got interested in | |||
supplementation and exercise | |||
'cause it made me feel better, | |||
but I also want to know what | |||
was going on under the hood. | |||
So you get numbers back, you | |||
get this hormone, that hormone, | |||
this blood glucose measure, et cetera. | |||
How do you make sense of the data? | |||
I mean, what InsideTracker is doing aside, | |||
how do you personally | |||
make sense of the data | |||
in ways that might differ from the way | |||
that a standard MD might | |||
look at one of these charts? | |||
Because the standard practice is to say, | |||
is it red, yellow, or green, right? | |||
Is it basically too high or too low? | |||
Is it somewhere close to | |||
the margins or are you okay? | |||
Are you in these ranges? | |||
Are there any things | |||
that you pay attention to | |||
that you think are | |||
particularly interesting | |||
for people to just take note of? | |||
I mean, we're not asking you | |||
to go against anybody's physician. | |||
But what sorts of things | |||
should people start | |||
to educate themselves about | |||
in terms of what these | |||
molecules are on their charts | |||
if they choose to get them, | |||
and what do you look at? | |||
- Yeah, well, there's a lot there. | |||
The first is that you | |||
should be tracking things, | |||
because one measurement isn't enough. | |||
These things vary and over time. | |||
And if you can have a | |||
decade or more of data, | |||
it's super important, informative, | |||
as you know, well know, as you know. | |||
So the physician, interestingly, | |||
my physician, let's | |||
take him as an example. | |||
So he sees me, he says, | |||
"How are you feeling?" | |||
"I'm feeling great." | |||
"Okay, see you next | |||
year," that's craziness. | |||
Anyway, so I say, okay, stop. | |||
Let's talk a little bit about. | |||
- Let me educate you, that's | |||
what David tells his physician. | |||
I imagine that the | |||
12-year-old David Sinclair | |||
says to a physician, | |||
"Listen, let's have a | |||
different discussion." | |||
Is that how it works? | |||
- It is. | |||
He finds me pretty annoying | |||
as does my dentist. | |||
But so I say, so hang | |||
on, I've got this data. | |||
I've got the InsideTracker data. | |||
So I pull that up on the screen, | |||
and I'm showing him the | |||
changes in my cholesterol | |||
and my CRP, which is | |||
inflammatory marker as you know. | |||
And we're going through it, | |||
and you can see things change over time, | |||
and I've corrected them | |||
as they go slightly out of | |||
the optimal range for me, | |||
which is different than | |||
what he would do, of course. | |||
But what was funny is that he says, | |||
this is great, I love this data. | |||
But I'm not allowed to get | |||
this because of course, | |||
the insurance companies won't pay for it. | |||
So again, you can pay out of pocket. | |||
It's not super expensive. | |||
I would say, if you save a | |||
bit of money on a coffee, | |||
you can afford this kind of stuff. | |||
But the main point is that | |||
doctors do like this data. | |||
It's just that they're | |||
unable to spend the money | |||
on every one of their patients to get it. | |||
- Is there a code word | |||
that someone can use with their physician | |||
that will trigger a | |||
comprehensive blood test? | |||
I keep trying to figure | |||
out what's the code | |||
that one needs to ask | |||
or tell their doctor, | |||
I'm feeling blank so that | |||
they get a full blood panel. | |||
- Well. | |||
- Do you have to be hemorrhaging | |||
from the gut or something? | |||
- Well, I usually use the WTH method, | |||
which is what the hell? | |||
And then he says, "Okay, we'll do it." | |||
- 'Cause I think a lot of | |||
people out there are thinking, | |||
look, I'd love to have blood | |||
work repeatedly over time, | |||
but that's hard to get | |||
for financial reasons, | |||
but also a lot of people | |||
just don't know how | |||
to approach the conversation. | |||
And this is one of the things | |||
that I hope that we can educate people on, | |||
that they deserve to know what's | |||
going on inside their body, | |||
and that it makes a | |||
doctor's visit worthwhile, | |||
and that you don't have to | |||
feign illness in order to do it. | |||
- Right, yeah, and a lot of people do. | |||
So I would say, if you | |||
can't afford these tests, | |||
there are increasing number of companies | |||
that offer these tests, | |||
InsideTracker is one of them. | |||
And you just do it a couple | |||
of times a year at a minimum. | |||
And then you can share | |||
that with your doctor. | |||
If you can't afford that, then | |||
I would say to your doctor, | |||
here are the main ones | |||
that Andrew and David do. | |||
- Yep, and we must. | |||
And there's an email | |||
that is something like 555, | |||
or a phone number, rather, it's 555-5555. | |||
I think if they have any complaints, | |||
they can just call that number. | |||
David will pick up on the | |||
east coast business hours | |||
and I'll pick up outside of those hours. | |||
- But there was the | |||
main ones, I would say. | |||
Your blood sugar levels, | |||
you want to do your HbA1c, | |||
which is your average glucose | |||
levels over the month. | |||
There's CRP, which I | |||
mentioned for inflammation. | |||
- Yeah, let's talk about | |||
C-reactive protein for a second. | |||
'Cause I think it's been shown | |||
to be an early marker | |||
of macular degeneration | |||
of heart disease, of a | |||
variety of different things. | |||
CRP is something | |||
that we don't hear enough about, I think. | |||
Maybe, what do you know | |||
about CRP that I don't, | |||
I'm guessing a lot, but. | |||
- Oh, it was originally picked up | |||
as something that was | |||
associated with heart disease | |||
in the Framingham study, I believe. | |||
It is the best marker for | |||
cardiovascular inflammation | |||
and is also, we use it as | |||
a predictor of longevity, | |||
and its levels go up with mortality. | |||
And so this is an association, | |||
but there's enough data that I would say, | |||
if you have high levels of CRP, | |||
you need to get your levels down quickly. | |||
And the levels usually go up with age | |||
and with levels of inflammation. | |||
So the ways to get it down | |||
would be to switch the diet, | |||
eat less, try to eat more vegetables. | |||
You'll find it will come down, | |||
and there are also drugs that can do it. | |||
Anti-inflammatories can do it as well. | |||
But CRP is, it's actually, hCRP, | |||
there's a high sensitive | |||
hCRP, your doctor will know. | |||
Get one of those readings. | |||
'Cause if you've got | |||
normal blood sugar levels, | |||
your doctor, or fasting | |||
blood sugar levels, | |||
your doctor might say you're fine. | |||
But a lot of people | |||
have normal blood sugar, | |||
but have high CRP, which is | |||
just as bad for you longterm, | |||
and can predict a future heart attack. | |||
- On the lines of heart attack. | |||
I want your thoughts on cholesterol | |||
and serum cholesterol | |||
and dietary cholesterol. | |||
I cannot, for the life of me, | |||
get my arms around this literature. | |||
And even if I ignore all | |||
the essentially nonsense | |||
that's out there in various | |||
social media groups, | |||
as saying cholesterol is the | |||
worst thing in the world, | |||
or cholesterol is not, | |||
or dietary cholesterol has nothing to do | |||
with serum cholesterol and | |||
nothing to do with longevity. | |||
I can't seem to sort | |||
through the very basic data | |||
that essentially ask, | |||
is having high levels of LDL | |||
going to kill me earlier? | |||
Should I be striving to always | |||
reduce LDL and increase HDL? | |||
Is that a reasonable goal? | |||
And if so, | |||
is dietary cholesterol the | |||
primary determinant of that? | |||
And just as a final point about this, | |||
I am aware of quite good data | |||
that shows that anorexics, | |||
people that essentially eat no food, | |||
unless you force them to, | |||
can often have very high LDL. | |||
So their dietary cholesterol | |||
is essentially zero, | |||
and so they're manufacturing | |||
a lot of their own. | |||
So realize this isn't your | |||
primary area of expertise, | |||
but you're a smart guy | |||
and you think about this | |||
kind of stuff a lot. | |||
What do you think is going on | |||
with the cholesterol literature? | |||
And will we ever get to the bottom of this | |||
as a scientific and medical community? | |||
Because to me, it is rather perplexing. | |||
- It is, but you can get | |||
through the politics. | |||
I know a fair bit about cholesterol | |||
'cause it's in my family history. | |||
And I was headed for an early death, | |||
my grandmother had a stroke 30, | |||
that's how bad I am in | |||
terms of my genetics. | |||
So I went on a statin, and I | |||
know there's a lot of people | |||
who say that statins long-term are bad. | |||
It's associated with Alzheimer's disease. | |||
I've been taking a statins since I was 29. | |||
And that's 'cause I forced my same doctor | |||
to give me the statin, | |||
the conversation was something like this. | |||
You're too young to be on a statin. | |||
And I said, what? | |||
You want me to have a heart attack | |||
before you give me | |||
something, give it to me now. | |||
So 29, I'd been on a satin, | |||
and my cholesterol was | |||
way up in beyond 300, | |||
which is a massive mess up. | |||
Basically my blood was creamy to look at. | |||
So I've now got my cholesterol down | |||
to low, low levels to what would it be. | |||
You can check on my InsideTracker, | |||
but so my ratio of HDL to LDL, | |||
which you want to be less | |||
than five, is now two, | |||
and the LDL is below a | |||
hundred, so it's all good. | |||
And I've measured my | |||
cardiovascular health with an MRI. | |||
I've got a movie of my heart beating. | |||
I've still got a heart of a | |||
20-year old, so that's working, | |||
I'm willing to forgo the risk | |||
that the statin is causing problems later | |||
because of my family history. | |||
But other people, I would say, | |||
be aware that statins | |||
aren't perfect drugs. | |||
There were some interesting new ones. | |||
There's one called the PCSK9 inhibitor, | |||
which is, I think fortnightly, | |||
every two weeks injection, | |||
that blocks the release | |||
of LDL from the liver. | |||
And then that seems to be | |||
great for lowering cholesterol, | |||
but also has other benefits | |||
that might be prolongevity. | |||
And there were some people | |||
that I was just talking to | |||
on the cutting edge of this, | |||
and their doctors are | |||
trying them on this drug | |||
instead of the statin. | |||
So you could talk to your doctor about. | |||
- Do you avoid dietary | |||
cholesterol for that reason also? | |||
Red meat, butter. | |||
I mean, I have been to love butter. | |||
I love red meat. | |||
I realized there's some people who don't. | |||
My cholesterol is a little bit high, | |||
but I'm working to bring that down a bit, | |||
although not by altering | |||
my food intake yet. | |||
But what do you think is the relationship | |||
between dietary cholesterol | |||
and serum cholesterol, | |||
and what's going on with the liver? | |||
Why are anorexics? | |||
Why is there a certain cholesterol so high | |||
when they're eating nothing? | |||
- Well, there've been in a | |||
number of papers over the years | |||
that have been ignored. | |||
And our friend, Peter Attia, | |||
brought to my attention recently, | |||
a new study that I think definitively said | |||
that dietary cholesterol | |||
has almost zero impact | |||
on blood cholesterol levels. | |||
- Good. | |||
- Yeah, so I'm annoyed | |||
'cause I'd been avoiding eggs | |||
and butter for most of my | |||
life and I didn't have to. | |||
So I have eggs- | |||
- Plenty of time, or | |||
at least in your case. | |||
- Yeah, yeah. | |||
So that's the thing. | |||
You can eat these foods | |||
that were ones banned | |||
because it's very difficult | |||
to take cholesterol up | |||
into the body from the gut. | |||
And most of it's being | |||
synthesized in the body. | |||
- Well, I'm just pausing | |||
there for a second | |||
because I think that it's | |||
what we've been told. | |||
Six meals a day, eat a | |||
lot of grains and fruits | |||
and this kind of thing, avoid cholesterol. | |||
I mean, basically everything we learned | |||
in the '80s and '90s and early 2000s | |||
is getting flipped on its head now. | |||
But, and I think this | |||
is a very strong caveat | |||
that's important to mention, amino acids. | |||
In particular, the amino acids | |||
that come from animal products, right? | |||
Seem to have some pro aging | |||
effect on them, right? | |||
At least the way that I've | |||
heard you describe your diet. | |||
And I'm somebody who | |||
enjoys meat, I like it. | |||
But so I'm by no means, a vegan at all. | |||
But I've heard you say | |||
you eat mostly plants, | |||
but a little bit of fish | |||
or chicken or something | |||
of that sort of eggs or. | |||
But is that specifically | |||
to avoid excessive amino acid intake? | |||
Or is it something specific about plants | |||
that excites you with | |||
respect to? [chuckles] | |||
I mean, vegetables are | |||
delicious too, but what is it? | |||
Is it something great about plants | |||
or is it something bad | |||
about when I think of meat, | |||
I guess the biologist in me | |||
thinks amino acids, right? | |||
I don't think top sirloin, | |||
I think amino acids. | |||
And I think top sirloin as I'm eating it, | |||
but really what they are, are amino acids, | |||
including leucine. | |||
- Yeah, well, there are two | |||
good things about plants, | |||
and neither of them is taste for me. | |||
I would eat steak all the time if I could. | |||
I did when I was a kid, I'm an Australian. | |||
But plants have two benefits. | |||
One is that they're highly nutritious, | |||
and they'll give you a lot of the vitamins | |||
and nutrients that I need. | |||
I don't take multivitamin, | |||
I don't want to have the | |||
excess iron in my body. | |||
So there's that high density nutrition. | |||
So those dark leaves, if | |||
it's a spinach salad, great. | |||
The second is that there | |||
is what's called xenohormetic | |||
molecules in plants. | |||
That term, xenohormesis is a term | |||
that I came up with | |||
with my friend, Conrad. | |||
How it's, which means | |||
stressed plants make molecules | |||
that benefit your health. | |||
I'll break it down. | |||
Xeno means between species, | |||
and hormesis is the term, | |||
whatever doesn't kill | |||
you makes you stronger | |||
and live longer. | |||
And the idea is that when | |||
plants are stressed out, | |||
think of a great vine that's dried out | |||
and then starting to harvest the grapes, | |||
which is typically how it's done. | |||
They are full with resveratrol, | |||
because resveratrol is | |||
a plant defense molecule | |||
that I think is made | |||
to activate those | |||
sirtuin genes in a plant. | |||
So plants have sirtuins just like we do. | |||
But by purifying or at least concentrating | |||
in a light-proof bottle and | |||
keeping it out of the air, | |||
we stabilize the xenohormetic molecule, | |||
or it's a cocktail, not just | |||
one, there's others in wine. | |||
We then ingest those and get the benefits | |||
of activating our own defenses, | |||
because our food was getting stressed out. | |||
And by stressed, I don't mean | |||
psychologically stressed. | |||
I mean, biologically stressed. | |||
And so I try to eat plants | |||
that have gone through a bit of stress. | |||
They might be brightly colored, | |||
they've had too much sun | |||
or got nibbled on by a caterpillar. | |||
So you go to places where it's | |||
organic or it's fresh, local, | |||
and those are the plants | |||
that aren't perfect, | |||
and they probably have high concentrations | |||
of these molecules. | |||
And in addition, I also | |||
buy the supplements | |||
to make sure I'm getting | |||
enough of those as well. | |||
- Which supplements mimic that? | |||
- So resveratrol will, | |||
there's another one called quercetin, | |||
or quercetin, some people call it, | |||
what you find in trace | |||
amounts in apples and onions. | |||
And we also showed back in 2003 | |||
that it activates sirtuins as well. | |||
But others have, 20 years later, | |||
found that it kills senescent cells | |||
or helps kill senescent cells. | |||
So it's a double whammy | |||
with that molecule. | |||
- And are you actively | |||
picking out the peaches | |||
that look like they were | |||
nibbled on by a caterpillar? | |||
- No, but I don't worry if | |||
they've been banged up a bit. | |||
- What's the story with antioxidants? | |||
Are they of any value whatsoever, | |||
because the way that you | |||
describe them at the beginning, | |||
and what I've heard recently | |||
is that they are not all | |||
the rage for anti-aging. | |||
What are they doing that's useful? | |||
Should we be seeking | |||
out antioxidants anyway | |||
for other seller health purposes? | |||
- Well, yeah, antioxidants | |||
are not going to hurt you | |||
unless you take mega doses. | |||
We do need some oxidants | |||
for our immune system. | |||
And there's even, what's | |||
called mitohormesis, | |||
which is your mitochondria power packs, | |||
need to have a little bit | |||
of these free radicals | |||
to be able to function. | |||
So you don't want to overdose | |||
on these antioxidants, | |||
vitamin C, vitamin E, don't overdo it. | |||
- You don't take a multivitamin, correct? | |||
- Right. | |||
- I think I'm going to stop | |||
after this conversation | |||
'cause I've always just taken one | |||
for the kind of insurance purpose, | |||
which is a stupid purpose. | |||
Not actual insurance, but just thinking, | |||
oh cap top off on my ACBD. | |||
- Right, and I'll pee out what | |||
I don't need, right, sure. | |||
- But that never bothered me. | |||
The whole expensive pee thing never got. | |||
That argument never got | |||
made because of that. | |||
A good vitamin is not that expensive. | |||
I just figured better safe than sorry, | |||
but it may be that it's detrimental. | |||
- Well, it can in the case of iron | |||
as we discussed and the antioxidants. | |||
So when I came into the aging | |||
field in the early 1990s, | |||
it was all about antioxidants. | |||
And we thought that enzymes | |||
by the name of catalyze | |||
and superoxide dismutase, well, | |||
they're going to be the key to longevity. | |||
It turns out that it's | |||
largely been a failure | |||
that giving animals and | |||
humans antioxidants, | |||
haven't had the longevity | |||
benefits that we dreamed of. | |||
And the main reason is that | |||
there's a lot more going on | |||
than just free radical damage. | |||
The epigenome gets disrupted, | |||
we've got these proteins misfolding. | |||
And so the problem really has | |||
been that we didn't realize | |||
that you need to turn on | |||
the body's natural defenses against that | |||
plus a whole host of other | |||
things to get the true benefits. | |||
But I'm not going to say | |||
it's a problem taking it, | |||
an antioxidant drink, | |||
pomegranate juice for one | |||
is full of good stuff, | |||
including xenohormetic molecules. | |||
But resveratrol is a good case in point, | |||
which is when I worked on resveratrol | |||
as a longevity molecule, | |||
first we showed it in yeast | |||
and worms and flies and mice. | |||
Before that, it was | |||
thought that resveratrol | |||
was good for your heart in red | |||
wine when you drink red wine, | |||
because it's an antioxidant. | |||
So then we showed that | |||
it extended the lifespan | |||
of yeast cells through this | |||
genetic pathway, the sirtuins. | |||
And we then tested whether resveratrol, | |||
if we change one atom | |||
to make it not an antioxidant, guess what? | |||
It still worked fine. | |||
So it wasn't its anti-oxidant activity | |||
that was extending lifespan. | |||
It was its ability to turn on | |||
the yeast's defenses against aging. | |||
Conversely, when we gave | |||
the yeast antioxidants, | |||
they lived shorter. | |||
So yeah, that was the | |||
beginning of my transformation | |||
into thinking turn on the body's defenses, | |||
don't give it the antioxidants. | |||
- This is an opportunity | |||
for me to say something | |||
that I've been wanting | |||
to say for a long time, | |||
which is that, what's so | |||
wonderful about science | |||
is that because the goal is mechanism, | |||
you can really start to understand | |||
as you just described, what | |||
actually mediates a process | |||
is very different than | |||
what modulates a process. | |||
I mean, if a fire alarm goes | |||
off in the building right now, | |||
it's going to modulate our attention. | |||
That doesn't mean that it | |||
controls our attention, | |||
it's not mechanistically relevant. | |||
And so I think this | |||
thing about antioxidants | |||
is one of these cases, | |||
it sounds like where it's | |||
in the right ballpark, | |||
but until one really unveils | |||
the mechanism as you have, | |||
you can be, one can or in a field, | |||
can be badly wrong for a | |||
very long period of time. | |||
It sounds like the sirtuins | |||
and really getting down to | |||
the guts of the machinery | |||
of what causes cells to age | |||
is really what it's about. | |||
Zooming way out, what | |||
are the behavioral tools | |||
that one can start to think about | |||
in terms of ways to modulate these? | |||
Basically the way that DNA | |||
is being expressed and functioning. | |||
I've heard you talk before | |||
about hormesis of other | |||
sorts, cold exposure. | |||
We talked about fasting. | |||
We talked about exercise in broad terms, | |||
but what about any evidence, if it exists, | |||
as to whether or not aerobic training | |||
versus weight training, | |||
these sorts of things. | |||
In other words, what | |||
are the sorts of things | |||
that people can do to improve | |||
their sirtuin pathway? | |||
And I realized that there are caveats. | |||
We can't go directly from | |||
a behavior dissertations, | |||
but in the general theme, | |||
what can people do, what do you do? | |||
- Right, well, we know | |||
that that aerobic exercise | |||
in mice and rats raises their NAD levels | |||
and their levels of sirt, | |||
one of the genes goes up | |||
two actually, number one and number three. | |||
What we don't know yet | |||
is what type of exercise | |||
is optimal to get them to change. | |||
We will learn, we're doing work. | |||
Now it's revealed that we're doing work | |||
with the military in the US, | |||
to try and understand that kind of thing. | |||
And I'll always tell you and the public, | |||
when I don't know something | |||
I'm not going to extrapolate. | |||
But what do I do? | |||
I base my exercise on the | |||
scientific literature, | |||
which has shown that | |||
maintaining muscle mass | |||
is very important for a number of reasons. | |||
The two main ones are, | |||
you want to maintain your hormone levels. | |||
I'm an older male, | |||
losing my testosterone | |||
and muscle mass over time. | |||
And by exercising, I will | |||
maintain that and have, | |||
in fact, I probably haven't | |||
had a body like this | |||
since I was 20. | |||
So that's one of the benefits | |||
of having this lifestyle. | |||
- Sorry to interrupt you. | |||
You do know we did an episode on hormones | |||
and there are data in humans | |||
that show that there are some | |||
males in their '80s and '90s | |||
where their testosterone is equivalent | |||
to the average of 25 and 30-year-olds. | |||
I can get you that information, | |||
is really impressive studies. | |||
Unfortunately, they didn't | |||
include a lot of information | |||
about the lifestyle factors, et cetera. | |||
But this idea that testosterone | |||
goes down with age, | |||
it might be the trend, | |||
but it's not necessarily a prerequisite. | |||
- Right, I believe in naturally increasing | |||
and maintaining these hormone levels | |||
and I've been measuring | |||
them for a long time. | |||
And I could see for me, | |||
my testosterone levels | |||
were steadily, levels were going down. | |||
- And then you got tenure | |||
and they went back up again. | |||
[both chuckle] | |||
- No, I actually became complacent. | |||
And it was the worst. | |||
Actually my age changed in the | |||
wrong direction after that, | |||
'cause I was relaxed. | |||
- Interesting. | |||
- And not worried about the future. | |||
But then I got serious. | |||
And I actually, according to | |||
the InsideTracker algorithm, | |||
got my age down from 58 to | |||
31 in a matter of months. | |||
So that was a big drop. | |||
And I've been getting steadily younger | |||
over the last 10 years, | |||
according to that | |||
measurement, the blood test. | |||
- What about estrogen? | |||
Because women are different in the sense | |||
that they do the number of eggs that they, | |||
and the ovaries change over time, right? | |||
Do you think that they can | |||
maintain estrogen levels | |||
in over longer periods of time | |||
using some of these same protocols? | |||
- Well, yeah, I get into trouble | |||
from a certain university | |||
when I talk about this too much. | |||
- About estrogen? | |||
- Just about fertility and long story. | |||
I don't want to get too | |||
much into the anecdotes, | |||
but I'll tell you the science, | |||
which is that if you take a | |||
mouse and put it on fasting | |||
or caloric restriction | |||
for up until the point | |||
where it should be in fertile, | |||
so that's about at a year of age, | |||
a mouse gets infertile, female mouse. | |||
- Due to fasting or | |||
due to simply to aging? | |||
- Due to aging, due to aging. | |||
The fasting, it's not extreme fast, | |||
it's just less calories. | |||
Then you put them back on a regular food, | |||
and they become fertile again | |||
for many, many months afterwards. | |||
So the effect on slowing down aging | |||
is also on the reproductive system. | |||
- Interesting. | |||
- And so that, I wouldn't | |||
say to any woman, | |||
I wouldn't think that they | |||
should become super skinny | |||
to try and preserve fertility, | |||
that's not what I'm saying. | |||
But these pathways that we work on these, | |||
sirtuins are known to delay | |||
infertility in female animals. | |||
Case in point, I'm one of the lead authors | |||
on a paper where we used NMN. | |||
Remember, this is the gas, the fuel, | |||
the petrol for the sirtuins. | |||
We gave old mice. | |||
One group of mice was 16 months old. | |||
Remember they became infertile | |||
at 12, gave them NMN. | |||
And I think it was only six weeks later, | |||
they had offspring. | |||
They became fertile again, | |||
which goes against biology, | |||
the textbook biology, | |||
which is that female | |||
mammals run out of eggs. | |||
Turns out that's not true. | |||
You can rejuvenate the | |||
female reproductive system, | |||
and even get them to | |||
come out of mouseopause | |||
as we call it. | |||
So that's a whole new | |||
paradigm in biology as well. | |||
- That's super interesting. | |||
Sorry to interrupt you, | |||
but I'm reminded by a set of studies | |||
that were done by your former colleagues | |||
'cause they're no longer there, | |||
David Hubel and Torsten Wiesel, | |||
my scientific great grandparents. | |||
Won the Nobel prize for discovering, | |||
what are called critical periods, | |||
this phase of early development | |||
when the brain is extremely plastic. | |||
And a big part of their work | |||
was to show that after a certain point, | |||
the critical period shuts down, | |||
essentially the brain can't | |||
change or not nearly as much. | |||
And then people came | |||
along later and showed | |||
that you could open up these | |||
critical periods again, | |||
but very briefly, | |||
and it takes a very specific | |||
stimulus, essentially, | |||
high degrees of focus, et cetera. | |||
However, there's a well-known | |||
phenomenon in this literature | |||
where if you take an | |||
animal and to some degree, | |||
this has been shown in humans as well, | |||
and you let them pass | |||
through the critical period, | |||
but then you essentially | |||
sensory deprive them. | |||
You take away experience, | |||
you close both eyes. | |||
You essentially reopen | |||
the critical period. | |||
So it seems like I couldn't | |||
help but mention this, | |||
that there's this parallel | |||
between what we're talking | |||
about here with fertility | |||
and neuroplasticity, where yes, | |||
there is a timer where | |||
certain things are available | |||
to the organism early in life, | |||
and then they tend to taper off. | |||
It's not an open and | |||
shut, but they taper off. | |||
But then a deprivation | |||
can actually reactivate | |||
the availability of that process. | |||
Forgive me, I just couldn't | |||
help him mention it, | |||
but to me, | |||
so both of those things | |||
are associated with youth, | |||
fertility and neuroplasticity. | |||
And so I think that | |||
it'd be so interesting. | |||
I'd love to collaborate with you on this | |||
to explore how neuroplasticity | |||
might actually be regulated | |||
by these things like the sirtuins. | |||
- Right, and the sirtuins | |||
do control memory | |||
in neurons as well. | |||
So what I think is really interesting | |||
is that what we're learning from work | |||
that you and your colleagues have done | |||
and in my lab as well, | |||
is that the body has | |||
remarkable powers of healing | |||
and recovering from illness and injury. | |||
And what we once thought | |||
was a one-way street | |||
and you just can't repair, | |||
or you can't get over these diseases, | |||
you can reset the system, | |||
and the body can really get rejuvenated | |||
in ways that in the future will wonder, | |||
why didn't we work on this earlier? | |||
The future of humanity | |||
is more like us walking | |||
around like Deadpool. | |||
We'll probably be cleaner, | |||
and we won't smell as badly, | |||
but Deadpool, if you don't know, | |||
can get injured and just recover. | |||
It's very hard to injure this guy, | |||
and we're going to be the same. | |||
There are many species | |||
you cut off the limb, | |||
the limb grows back. | |||
- Salamanders or. | |||
- Yeah. | |||
We are now learning how | |||
to tap into that system. | |||
And in part, what we're doing | |||
is reversing the age of those cells, | |||
and telling them how to read | |||
the genes correctly again, | |||
reversing the age of that epigenome. | |||
And when you do that, the cells, | |||
the brain, for instance, the skin. | |||
We did the optic nerve. | |||
- Let's talk about those | |||
results for a second. | |||
Then I want to make sure that we return | |||
to some of these behavioral protocols. | |||
You have this amazing paper | |||
at the end of last year, | |||
cover article, full article in nature, | |||
showing that essentially a small menu | |||
of transcription factors, | |||
which control gene expression, et cetera, | |||
could essentially reverse | |||
the age of neurons in the eye | |||
and rescue those cells against damage. | |||
Essentially allow blind mice to see again, | |||
and offset degeneration | |||
of these retinal cells, | |||
incredible paper, and | |||
such a boom to the field. | |||
Where does that stand now in | |||
terms of human clinical trials? | |||
I mean, how do, what are you envisioning | |||
in terms of the trajectory of those data | |||
from mice into human someday? | |||
- Right, well, to get to | |||
the point immediately, | |||
we're going to be testing | |||
the treatment on monkeys, | |||
just for safety reasons. | |||
And then the first patient | |||
should be done sometime in 2022, | |||
early 2023, and we're going | |||
to try to recover blindness. | |||
- This involves making an injection | |||
of a virus into the eye, right? | |||
Right now, there's no | |||
way that I am aware of | |||
to manipulate these transcription factors | |||
through a pill or some other? | |||
- And that's why, we working on in my lab | |||
at Harvard right now. | |||
So it will be- | |||
- It will base moderation of- | |||
- Well you pop a pill in the whole body | |||
gets rejuvenated by 20 years. | |||
That's what we're aiming for. | |||
Now we do it with gene therapy | |||
in the eye and other places. | |||
So in the IES, it's single injection, | |||
the genes go into the retina | |||
and we can turn it on, | |||
with a drug called doxycycline. | |||
And we do that in the mice | |||
for four to eight weeks, | |||
then the eye gets younger. | |||
We can measure that' cause | |||
you can measure the clock. | |||
And then the vision | |||
comes back in those mice. | |||
And I don't see any reason, | |||
why it shouldn't work in people | |||
because it's the same structures | |||
and mechanisms that are | |||
on in the human as well. | |||
Now these- | |||
- And it's one injection. | |||
- It's one. | |||
- I should mention injections into the eye | |||
obviously nobody should do this | |||
outside of a ophthalmology clinic. | |||
And there definitely by | |||
an ophthalmologist but, | |||
the injections into the eye | |||
are painless if done correctly | |||
by the right person. | |||
It sounds dreadful, but it's actually, | |||
I've seen it done hundreds of times. | |||
I've done it, thousands of times | |||
and it's not to myself, | |||
but to other creatures. | |||
And there's a way of doing this | |||
as completely painless to the person- | |||
- Oh you don't feel it. | |||
It's a tiny, tiny needle too. | |||
But the great thing about this is that | |||
it's a one-time treatment. | |||
Those genes go into the back | |||
of the eye and stay there, | |||
forever. | |||
And you can just turn | |||
them on whenever you want. | |||
So what we found is you can | |||
turn them on in the mice, | |||
they get their vision back, | |||
and then you turn it off again. | |||
And so far, many months out, | |||
the benefit has remained, | |||
but if it does decline, | |||
we'll just turn it back | |||
on and reset the system, | |||
rinse and repeat. | |||
So one day what's exciting is that | |||
we could potentially do | |||
this across the entire body | |||
and just take this antibiotic, | |||
every five years and go | |||
back time and time again. | |||
- And thinking about the body | |||
and what's going on under | |||
the head I'm amazed, | |||
still that there isn't a | |||
simple, affordable technology | |||
that would allow me to just | |||
look into my body and see | |||
whether or not there are | |||
any tumors growing anywhere. | |||
I mean, it's not that hard | |||
to look into the body. | |||
I mean that the technology exists. | |||
why hasn't anybody created an at home | |||
or pseudo at home solution, | |||
like a clinic where you can go | |||
and pay 50 bucks or a hundred bucks | |||
and see if you have any | |||
tumors growing anymore. | |||
- Yeah, it's still expensive. | |||
You can get your doctor | |||
to try to get you in, | |||
there's some companies | |||
that offer blood tests | |||
that look at circulating DNA, | |||
that'll measure it. | |||
We're getting there. | |||
It's still probably five to 10 years away | |||
from being really cheap. | |||
You can do things like a | |||
colon cancer test at home. | |||
I think it's a hundred | |||
and something dollars. | |||
You ship off your shit, | |||
excuse my language, | |||
and they measure it. | |||
And they tell you if | |||
you've got colon cancer, | |||
with high probability, | |||
I did that during the pandemic | |||
because I didn't want | |||
to get a colonoscopy. | |||
- Mhmh, is it more accurate or | |||
as accurate as a colonoscopy? | |||
- I believe it's close | |||
to being as accurate. | |||
The downside is that during a colonoscopy, | |||
they can pinch off the polyps | |||
that are looking dangerous, | |||
whereas this obviously isn't that, | |||
but it's certainly easier to do. | |||
And my father who's | |||
Australian tells me that | |||
it's free for Australians. | |||
They get this test routinely. | |||
- Mhmh, interesting. | |||
I want to return to the topic | |||
that I took us away from. | |||
So I apologize, which | |||
is behavioral protocols. | |||
Do you regularly do the cold shower thing? | |||
Ice baths, cold water swims, | |||
are you into that whole biz? | |||
[David chuckles] | |||
- Well, you do know that | |||
I've done it at least once | |||
'cause we did it together. | |||
- That's right. | |||
Not the same bath, just to be very clear, | |||
same sauna, different ice baths, | |||
[David chuckles] | |||
the idea of Sinclair | |||
and Huberman taking an | |||
ice bath together it's a, | |||
it might warm some people's hearts, | |||
but just to be very clear, different, | |||
same ice bath, different, different times. | |||
- Yeah, thank you for clarifying. | |||
- [Andrew] Yeah. | |||
I don't do them regularly. | |||
I do try to sleep cool. | |||
I sleep better anyway. | |||
I try to dress without | |||
a lot of warm clothes. | |||
I'm here in a T-shirt and | |||
it's middle of summer, | |||
but in winter, I'll try | |||
to wear a T-shirt too. | |||
- So you're challenging your | |||
system to thermoregulate? | |||
- Right, right. | |||
I've got this, | |||
hypothesis with Ray Cronise. | |||
We published what's called The | |||
Metabolic Winter Hypothesis, | |||
which is, few tens of | |||
thousands of years ago, | |||
we were either hungry or cold or both | |||
and we really experience that now. | |||
And so, we try to give | |||
ourselves the metabolic winter | |||
and part of the problem I | |||
think with the obesity epidemic | |||
is that we're never cold and cold, | |||
when you're cold you have to burn energy. | |||
It may be only slightly, | |||
but over the whole night, | |||
if you're a little bit cool, | |||
you'll actually expend more energy. | |||
So I try to do that, | |||
but I'm not a big fan of cold showers. | |||
The sauna, I don't have access | |||
to my gym as much as I did. | |||
So, but I do want to get back into it. | |||
I used to do it regularly with my son | |||
and I posted on Instagram once | |||
that he could stay in there for 15 minutes | |||
and I could only stay in for about three. | |||
Anyway, long story short, | |||
I try to compensate with | |||
changes in my diet and exercise | |||
until I get back into it. | |||
- You reminded me of something | |||
that I meant to ask earlier | |||
that obesity reduces NAD | |||
levels and accelerates aging. | |||
How? | |||
I mean, okay. | |||
So again, this is the, | |||
the scientist in the us, | |||
so someone's carrying a lot | |||
of excess adipose tissues, | |||
subcutaneous and, | |||
visceral fat. | |||
But why should that reduce NAD in any ways | |||
that are independent of | |||
effects on glucose and insulin? | |||
If it, you know, | |||
is there's something direct | |||
about white adipose tissue. | |||
And the reason I ask this, | |||
is not simply to dig into mechanism alone, | |||
but I think there are | |||
really interesting data now | |||
that fat actually gets neural innervation. | |||
I mean, | |||
it's not just a, | |||
it's not just stored fuel. | |||
It's stored fuel, | |||
that's acting as an | |||
endocrine organ, essentially. | |||
So, | |||
why would being fat | |||
make people age faster? | |||
- Yeah, that's a question that, | |||
is so obvious, but so few people ask it, | |||
that's what makes you a good scientist. | |||
And so that we don't know, | |||
but I'll give you my best | |||
answer, which is that, | |||
obesity comes along with | |||
a lot of problems that, | |||
include a lot of senescent cells in fat, | |||
if you stain old fat for | |||
senescent cells, it lights up. | |||
- Mhmh. | |||
And when you kill off those cells, | |||
at least in mice, and maybe in humans, | |||
it looks like the fat is | |||
less toxic to the body. | |||
'Cause those senescent cells | |||
in their fat are secreting | |||
these inflammatory molecules | |||
that will accelerate aging as we now know. | |||
We talk about the sirtuins in NAD. | |||
So if we, | |||
if we just look philosophically, | |||
at why this would be the sirtuins only, | |||
like to come on or get | |||
activated when the body needs, | |||
is on the right adversity. | |||
And if a cell is surrounded by | |||
fat or contains a lot of fat, | |||
it's going to think times a good, | |||
it doesn't need to switch on. | |||
So that's the evolutionary argument. | |||
Mechanistically, we don't know, | |||
but it could have something to do with | |||
the response to glucose, | |||
which then responds to the sirtuin gene, | |||
but that hasn't been worked out very well. | |||
- And is there any evidence that leptin, | |||
this hormone from fat can actually, | |||
interact with the sirtuin pathway? | |||
- I don't recall seeing that- | |||
- Maybe I could do a | |||
sabbatical in your lab | |||
and that'd be a fun one. | |||
- Definitely- | |||
- Because leptin during | |||
development is what triggers, | |||
the permission for the hypothalamus | |||
to enter puberty, right? | |||
- Yeah. | |||
- This is why kids that eat | |||
a lot when they're young | |||
and get overweight will also start to go | |||
and undergo puberty more quickly, | |||
although they have | |||
reproductive issues later. | |||
- Well yeah. | |||
We should study the | |||
hypothalamus together 'cause, | |||
the hypothalamus is, | |||
can control the aging of the body. | |||
- The most interesting part of the brain. | |||
[Andrew chuckles] | |||
- For sure. | |||
- Yeah, absolutely. | |||
- If you turn on the SIRT1 gene, | |||
the SIRT2 that we work | |||
on, in the hypothalamus | |||
that actually, will extend lifespan. | |||
Also, it's been shown by Dongsheng Cai | |||
at Albert Einstein College of Medicine, | |||
that if you, inhibit | |||
inflammation in the hypothalamus, | |||
in a mouse, it will increase | |||
or maintain the expression | |||
of what's called GnRH, | |||
which is the hormone that, | |||
he found actually controls | |||
longevity in the mouse in part. | |||
And so keeping inflammation | |||
down in the hypothalamus, | |||
is sufficient to extend | |||
the life span of animals. | |||
And I reviewed that paper for nature | |||
all about seven years ago. | |||
And that was the first demonstration | |||
that the hypothalamus is one | |||
of the leading regulators | |||
of the body's age. | |||
- I find this fascinating GnRH, | |||
for those of you that don't | |||
know actually comes from neurons | |||
in the hypothalamus that then, | |||
literally reached down into the pituitary | |||
and trigger the release of | |||
all the things that control | |||
fertility, luteinizing hormone, | |||
follicle-stimulating hormone, et cetera. | |||
It's such a powerful set of neurons, | |||
and it's never really been clear, | |||
what at a behavioral level | |||
triggers the release of GnRH. | |||
There's all the stories about pheromones | |||
and timers and puberty, et cetera, | |||
but environmental conditions | |||
and dietary conditions | |||
and behaviors that can | |||
control GnRH release, I think, | |||
is an incredible area for exploration. | |||
I'd love to do that sabbatical by the way. | |||
I have a couple, well | |||
seemingly random questions, | |||
but I can't help, but ask | |||
because one thing I like to do | |||
is forage the internet for | |||
practices that at least more than | |||
a few people are doing, | |||
and then wonder whether or | |||
not there's any basis for it. | |||
You mentioned methylation | |||
as a detrimental process, | |||
the way it disrupts the | |||
epigenome and the CD reader, | |||
so to speak. | |||
There are people out there who | |||
are ingesting methylene blue. | |||
And when I was a kid, | |||
I used methylene blue | |||
to clean my fish tank. | |||
And I love fish tanks. | |||
I know you're into aquaria also, | |||
a different podcast episode, | |||
we'll talk about aquaria, | |||
but why in the world, would | |||
people ingest methylene blue? | |||
Meaning is their logic correct? | |||
And or is that a dangerous practice? | |||
I'm not sure I'd want to | |||
ingest methylene blue, | |||
sounds not like a bad thing to do. | |||
- It stains your body if you've | |||
seen, yeah methylene blue- | |||
- Yeah, there was someone | |||
in my lab as a postdoc | |||
was using it to study a | |||
completely different process | |||
related to the blood-brain barrier | |||
and used to inject into animals | |||
and they would turn blue, | |||
but then again, people | |||
ingest colloid silver. | |||
You know they'll put | |||
in there, there's this, | |||
please people don't do this | |||
or if you do, just don't tell me, | |||
'cause I won't like it. | |||
They, people put it in their eyes | |||
and some people actually stain their skin. | |||
They actually become kind of | |||
a silver purple brown color | |||
if they do it excessively. | |||
I mean, there's a lot of | |||
crazy stuff out there. | |||
But what do you think they're thinking | |||
with this methylene blue thing | |||
or should we just get them | |||
to a good psychiatrist? | |||
- I don't know, for sure. | |||
I think methylene blue was found | |||
to extend the lifespan | |||
of some lower organism | |||
and that's where it came from. | |||
My recollection- | |||
- With the emphasis on lower organisms. | |||
- Yes smaller organisms. | |||
I think doesn't, do you | |||
remember Andrew does it, | |||
interrupt or interfere | |||
with mitochondrial activity | |||
and that's- | |||
- Maybe that's why the are doing it. | |||
- Yeah. | |||
- [Andrew] Okay. | |||
- We need to look this up and post it. | |||
- [Andrew] Okay. | |||
- We'll get to the bottom | |||
of this, but those methods, | |||
let's talk about those. | |||
- [Andrew] Yeah. | |||
- Those methods have to | |||
be placed on the right, | |||
part of the genome. | |||
They get attached to the right | |||
genes in the wrong genes. | |||
And if you have a lot of methylation, | |||
it's going to mess up the epigenome. | |||
Smoking will do that, lack of | |||
exercise, all that good stuff. | |||
So you, what you actually want | |||
to do is you want to measure it | |||
and make sure what you're | |||
doing with your body, | |||
is working. | |||
How do you know that if you do this | |||
or that is actually helping. | |||
And so you can test your age. | |||
I could take, a swab from your mouth | |||
and tell you how old you are biologically. | |||
And then we could work on | |||
trying to bring that down | |||
and actually there were anecdotes now, | |||
that people are reversing | |||
their age by a decade or more | |||
just by doing some of the | |||
things that we've talked about | |||
and some other cutting edge stuff | |||
that I'm going to write about. | |||
But yet, but you have to measure stuff. | |||
That's, I didn't want to | |||
forget to bring that up. | |||
I'm measuring stuff all the time. | |||
I have blood tests like you, | |||
I've got this monitor that | |||
stuck to my chest right now | |||
that's measuring myself | |||
a thousand times a second | |||
and I measure my biological age. | |||
- What's it measuring a | |||
thousand times a second? | |||
A huge list of things. | |||
- Yeah, yeah. | |||
So this, this little device is stuck here | |||
and it's for two weeks | |||
that you just recharge it | |||
or send it back and get a new one. | |||
It's got a body temperature movement, | |||
heart rate variability. | |||
It's an FDA approved | |||
device, it's not a toy. | |||
It's not one of these recreational things. | |||
It also listens to my voice, | |||
eventually will me if | |||
I need a psychiatrist | |||
or if I'm depressed, | |||
it will tell me how I sleep, obviously. | |||
But when you put all that data together | |||
and it's individualized and anonymized, | |||
it can now tell my doctor in real time, | |||
if I've got a cold that | |||
needs an antibiotic, | |||
or it's just a virus. | |||
If I am suffering from COVID-19 | |||
or even if I'm going to have | |||
a heart attack next week. | |||
And so these little devices | |||
are going to be with us | |||
all the time, instead of going | |||
to your doctor once a year, | |||
which is ludicrous. | |||
- I have to ask you about x-rays. | |||
'Cause every time I go through | |||
the scanner at the airport, | |||
I think, "Sinclair would never do this." | |||
And the argument I heard | |||
you give about this before | |||
was a really excellent one, which is that | |||
it's a low level amount of radiation, | |||
going through at the airport, | |||
but the argument is always, | |||
well, it's just as much as on the plane | |||
and your argument, your | |||
counter-argument I should say was, | |||
"Well then why would I | |||
want to do both, right? | |||
Why would?" | |||
So when you go to the airport, | |||
assuming you're not running late | |||
and you have to go | |||
through the standard line, | |||
what do you say to them? | |||
And do you say, "I'm David Sinclair." | |||
And then they shuttle | |||
you to your own line. | |||
What do you say? | |||
You do say, "I don't like this thing." | |||
Do you have to give them a reason? | |||
- No, you don't. | |||
You can say, "I don't want this." | |||
And they'll get annoyed | |||
'cause it's hard for them | |||
to pat you down, | |||
but you get a pat down and you you're done | |||
as long as you're not | |||
in a hurry, it's fine. | |||
If you want to pay for | |||
the TSA Pre in America | |||
or the way to get around those | |||
scanners, you can do that. | |||
So I travel a lot, so | |||
it's worth it anyway, | |||
but I just go through the metal detector, | |||
I don't get scanned. | |||
- And the metal detector | |||
doesn't have the same, | |||
same problem. | |||
And what about x-rays at the dentist? | |||
Yeah. | |||
- Well, you know one x-ray | |||
is not going to kill you. | |||
Two's not going to kill you, but I- | |||
- Three will kill you. | |||
No, I'm just kidding. | |||
[Andrew chuckles] | |||
- I try to limit it | |||
because it's cumulative. | |||
- Right. | |||
- And I went for six years | |||
without having a dental x-ray | |||
and then my last visit, I just gave up. | |||
I was tired of arguing with my dentist. | |||
So they gave me one, | |||
but they've got led coats on | |||
and they put lead all over your body. | |||
That's telling you something right there. | |||
And funnily enough, my | |||
teeth hadn't changed. | |||
Now you can balance that by saying, | |||
"Well, one x-ray, two x-ray, | |||
three x-rays is worth | |||
it if I have cavities." | |||
And that's true, | |||
you want to know what's in there, | |||
but doing it regularly, for me, | |||
I don't think it was worth it because it, | |||
my teeth are in perfect | |||
health and I've always been, | |||
I don't have any cavities, | |||
didn't have braces, | |||
they're fine. | |||
So stop scanning me. | |||
I mean, I know you have | |||
to pay for the machine, | |||
but you know, do I have a choice? | |||
Yes, so stop pressuring me. | |||
- You know, who shared your | |||
sentiments about x-rays | |||
and the dentist in general? | |||
My apologies to the dentists out there, | |||
was the great physicist, Richard Feynman. | |||
This is a story about him that's | |||
not especially well-known, | |||
but he had very serious | |||
concerns, health concerns, | |||
about x-rays because he | |||
understood the physics | |||
and he understood enough biology that, | |||
he was actually quite vocal about his, | |||
dislike of dental | |||
technology and its dangers. | |||
And he talked about some of that. | |||
People can find that on | |||
the internet, if they like. | |||
Speaking of people who, | |||
are like Feynman, | |||
who've been engaged in public | |||
discourse about science. | |||
One of the things that I | |||
appreciate about you, in fact, | |||
the way that you and I, | |||
initially came to know one | |||
another is through your | |||
public health education efforts. | |||
So, obviously we're doing this podcast, | |||
you've done the Joe Rogan Podcast, | |||
Lex Fridman's Podcast, excuse me Lex, | |||
I'm still adjusting that. | |||
Lex Fridman's Podcast | |||
and many other podcasts, | |||
you've written an amazing book. | |||
What are you thinking these days | |||
in terms of what the | |||
world needs in terms of, | |||
education from scientists, | |||
education from MDs, | |||
education in general as it | |||
relates to these things because, | |||
I think if nothing else | |||
2020 revealed to us that | |||
there's a gap, | |||
there's a gap in understanding. | |||
And that the scientists too are guilty of, | |||
not knowing what to do | |||
with all the information | |||
that's out there on pub med or elsewhere. | |||
I'm just, you know, | |||
what are you thinking for | |||
yourself and in general, | |||
I'd like to just know, | |||
what do you think the world needs there? | |||
Maybe we can recruit some | |||
more public educators. | |||
- Yeah. | |||
Well, we've gone from a | |||
time, when you and I were, | |||
in college and young | |||
professors where the only way, | |||
to get our voice out to | |||
the public was either | |||
through a newspaper or a | |||
very short radio interview, | |||
which for me was extremely | |||
frustrating 'cause particularly | |||
the newspapers and my topic, | |||
every time was twisted into something that | |||
was not just embarrassing, | |||
but Harvard university | |||
used to bring me into the back office and- | |||
- Frankenstein. | |||
- "How did you say such a thing? | |||
We're all going to live to a 250." | |||
I didn't say that. | |||
So, we're now also in a world where | |||
we're overwhelmed with information, | |||
and most of it is wrong | |||
and anyone can pretend to be an expert. | |||
So we've gone from early | |||
days to now the future, | |||
and we're experiencing it right now | |||
thanks to guys like you, people like you, | |||
is that the experts, some experts, | |||
a small number who are | |||
brilliant and good communicators | |||
are talking directly to the public. | |||
This has never been able to be possible, | |||
until this time, right now. | |||
So another five years from | |||
now, and certainly by 10 years, | |||
I would hope that there are | |||
trusted sources of information | |||
of people who can not just | |||
communicate, the ideas directly, | |||
but are able to talk about | |||
things that are going on that | |||
aren't even published yet to say, | |||
"Here's what's really going on. | |||
And this is what the future looks like." | |||
But this is somebody, like yourself | |||
who spent their whole life | |||
studying a particular topic | |||
and knows what they're talking about. | |||
And this, | |||
this is also something | |||
that I think most people | |||
don't know that we | |||
scientists, if we tell a lie, | |||
we burst into flames, | |||
we absolutely cannot tell | |||
something, that's untrue. | |||
And to the best of our | |||
knowledge, we say it as it is, | |||
because if we don't, we're beaten up, | |||
and we, or we kicked | |||
out of the university. | |||
So the people who survive to our age, | |||
and I'm a little older than you. | |||
So I've survived a bit longer. | |||
- But a lot younger inside. | |||
[Andrew chuckles] | |||
- Nah, but we have to measure you with- | |||
- Yeah we need, | |||
I probably need a little | |||
help, hopefully not too much. | |||
- We'll measure that, | |||
and we'll work on your | |||
eating, but this is really, | |||
really important is that, | |||
finally people like your are | |||
allowed by our universities | |||
to talk to the public. | |||
I used to do it, | |||
with a real threat to my survival. | |||
People would look at me, | |||
"Oh, he's a salesman, he's | |||
promoting this and that." | |||
It was seen as a real | |||
negative, but finally, | |||
I think we're in a world where, | |||
it's not negative anymore. | |||
And the pandemic showed that | |||
we needed voices of reason, | |||
voices of fact, that you could trust. | |||
And you can see the | |||
popularity of your podcast, | |||
shows that the public, | |||
they're desperate for | |||
facts that they can trust, | |||
'cause they don't know | |||
what to believe anymore. | |||
- Well, | |||
I'm being completely honest | |||
when I say this, that, | |||
you know, I followed your lead. | |||
I saw you on the Joe Rogan | |||
Podcast and my jaw dropped. | |||
I was like, "This is amazing, like this." | |||
Because, | |||
you get out other good | |||
scientists on before but, | |||
you're tenure Professor Harvard Genetics, | |||
Department of Genetics. | |||
And for those of you don't know, | |||
there's the Harvard and of | |||
course, Harvard Medical School | |||
and they're both excellent, of course, | |||
but these are the top, | |||
top tiers of academia. | |||
And I certainly understand | |||
what it takes to get there | |||
and survive there and to thrive there, | |||
it's like a game of pinball. | |||
You never win. | |||
You just, you just get to, | |||
if you're doing really well, | |||
you get to keep playing. | |||
And that's the truth in academia. | |||
And if you're not, you | |||
stop playing basically. | |||
But when I saw you, | |||
explain what you were doing | |||
in a way that was accessible to people | |||
and also talking about, | |||
possible protocols that they | |||
might explore for themselves | |||
to see if those were, right for them. | |||
I was just, I was just | |||
dazzled and excited, | |||
and I made every effort to | |||
get in contact with you. | |||
And, the rest is history, | |||
but, I think what's really | |||
exciting to me these days is | |||
because of 2020 and with | |||
everything that's happened | |||
and it continues to happen. | |||
There's a thirst for knowledge. | |||
There's also this direct | |||
to the public route | |||
that you mentioned. | |||
And, I think there's also an openness, | |||
I'd love your thoughts on this, | |||
but it seems to me that | |||
there's an openness in, | |||
from the general public, | |||
about health practices, | |||
that there are actually things | |||
that people can do to control | |||
their stress level, to control, | |||
their sleep, to control their cholesterol | |||
if that's what they to | |||
do, maybe they don't | |||
and to even control their lifespan, | |||
which I think is remarkable. | |||
And, I know I speak on | |||
behalf of so many people, | |||
when I just, | |||
I want to say, thank you. | |||
You've, truly changed | |||
the course of my life. | |||
I would not be sitting here doing this | |||
were it not for your example. | |||
And I always say Sinclair, | |||
many people have written books, | |||
many academics have | |||
written books, as you have, | |||
but in terms of doing podcasts | |||
and really getting out there | |||
with your message in a way that | |||
I have to assume raised | |||
your cortisol level | |||
and heart rate just a little bit, | |||
but you did it nonetheless. | |||
You are truly first man in and that, | |||
that deserves a nod. | |||
And, I have a great debt of | |||
gratitude to you for that. | |||
So thank you so much. | |||
- Oh thanks, Andrew. | |||
You're a, | |||
you've become a good friend | |||
and I'm super proud of what | |||
you've done and what you, | |||
I know what you will do. | |||
- So in addition to your book | |||
and your presence on social | |||
media, Instagram, and Twitter, | |||
and appearances on podcasts, | |||
recently I've noticed | |||
that you've opened up, | |||
a survey email/website | |||
that people can, access, | |||
excuse me, | |||
to get some information | |||
about their own health | |||
and rates of aging. | |||
Tell us about that and | |||
what's being measured. | |||
And what is this test that | |||
you've been working on, | |||
secretly and now soon, not so secretly. | |||
- Yeah, well that, | |||
what I want, | |||
is a credit score for | |||
the body to make it easy | |||
for people to follow their health. | |||
And there is a number, | |||
there's a, | |||
there's a biological age | |||
that you can measure. | |||
Unfortunately, | |||
the test is many hundreds | |||
of dollars right now, | |||
but in my lab, we've been | |||
able to bring that down a lot. | |||
And so I want to democratize this test | |||
so that everybody has access to a score | |||
for their health that can predict their, | |||
not just their future | |||
health and time of death, | |||
but to change it. | |||
And I'm building a system | |||
that will point people | |||
in the right direction | |||
and give them discounts for certain things | |||
that will improve, not | |||
just their health now, | |||
but 10, 20, 30 years into the future. | |||
And we can measure that, | |||
and very cheaply, keep | |||
measuring it to know | |||
that you're on the right track, | |||
'cause if you don't measure something, | |||
you can't optimize it. | |||
And so this is the biological age test, | |||
we've developed it, it's | |||
a simple mouth swab. | |||
We're rolling it out. | |||
We're building the system right now. | |||
And there was a sign up sheet | |||
'cause a lot of people | |||
want to get in line, | |||
go to doctorsinclair.com, | |||
you can get on that | |||
and you'll be one of the | |||
first people in the world | |||
to get this test and see what we're doing. | |||
- Oh, fantastic. | |||
Will people be celebrating their, | |||
biological age birthdays? | |||
In other words, if I'm | |||
minus, like if I can imagine, | |||
so I'm 45 right now, soon to be 46. | |||
But if I, | |||
if I were to be so lucky as | |||
to get my biological age to 35 | |||
within 12 months, maybe | |||
you can help me do that. | |||
Do I get to celebrate, | |||
a negative birthday? | |||
- Absolutely. | |||
And my plan is that those | |||
people who take their age back | |||
a year or more, we think we can | |||
go back 20 years eventually, | |||
they'll get a birthday card from me | |||
and it's a negative birthday card. | |||
[Andrew chuckles] | |||
- I love it. | |||
And probably very little, | |||
actual birthday cake being ingested but, | |||
who cares 'cause you're | |||
living that much longer. | |||
- That's full of stevia,* that'll be fine. | |||
[Both chuckle] | |||
And thank you for talking to us today. | |||
I realized I took us down deep | |||
into the guts of mechanism | |||
and as well, talking | |||
about global protocols, | |||
everything from what one can | |||
do and take if they choose, | |||
that's right for them to, | |||
how to think about this | |||
whole process that, | |||
that we talk about when | |||
we talk about lifespan | |||
as always an incredibly illuminating. | |||
Thank you, David. | |||
- Thanks Andrew. | |||
- Thank you for joining | |||
me for my conversation | |||
with Dr David Sinclair. | |||
If you're enjoying and or | |||
learning from this podcast, | |||
please subscribe to our YouTube channel. | |||
In addition, please subscribe | |||
on Apple and or Spotify. | |||
And on YouTube, you can leave us comments | |||
and you can leave us suggestions, | |||
for future podcast guests that | |||
you would like us to feature. | |||
In addition on Apple, you can leave us | |||
up to a five star review and | |||
you can leave us a comment. | |||
Please also check out | |||
the sponsors mentioned | |||
at the beginning of this episode, | |||
that's the best way to | |||
support this podcast. | |||
Also, I teach science | |||
and science related tools on Instagram. | |||
It's hubermanlab on Instagram. | |||
I also have a Twitter | |||
which has also hubermanlab. | |||
So be sure to check those out. | |||
A lot of the material, | |||
covers things similar to the podcast, | |||
but oftentimes I'll | |||
cover a unique material, | |||
not featured at all on the podcast. | |||
So that's hubermanlab on | |||
Instagram and on Twitter. | |||
In addition, we have a Patreon, | |||
it's patreon.com/andrewhuberman. | |||
And there you can support the podcast | |||
at any level that you like. | |||
Today, and in many other | |||
previous episodes of | |||
the Huberman Lab Podcast, | |||
we discuss supplements. | |||
While supplements aren't | |||
necessary or right for everybody, | |||
many people derive tremendous | |||
benefit from supplements. | |||
For that reason, we partnered with Thorne, | |||
T-H-O-R-N-E, | |||
because Thorne Supplements | |||
are the absolute highest quality | |||
and the absolute highest precision, | |||
meaning what you see listed on the bottle | |||
is what's actually in the bottle, | |||
which is not the case | |||
for many supplement companies out there. | |||
Thorne is one of the | |||
partners of the Mayo Clinic | |||
and all the major sports teams. | |||
And so they really are very | |||
trusted, very highest quality. | |||
If you want to see the supplements | |||
that I personally take, | |||
you can go to thorne.com/u/huberman, | |||
and there you'll see the | |||
supplements that I take, | |||
you can get 20% off any | |||
of those supplements. | |||
And if you navigate deeper | |||
into the Thorne site, | |||
through that portal, | |||
you'll also get 20% off any | |||
of the other supplements | |||
that Thorne makes. | |||
So again, it's Thorne, | |||
thorne.com/u/huberman | |||
to get 20% off any of the | |||
supplements that Thorne makes. | |||
Also take note that the | |||
lifespan podcast featuring | |||
Dr David Sinclair as a host, | |||
launches Wednesday, January 5th, | |||
you can find the first episode here | |||
on the Huberman Lab Podcast channel. | |||
They also have their | |||
own independent channel. | |||
You can find the link to that | |||
channel in the show notes. | |||
So please go there, subscribe on YouTube, | |||
also on Apple and Spotify. | |||
I've seen these episodes, | |||
they are phenomenal, | |||
and you're going to learn | |||
a tremendous amount, | |||
about aging and how to | |||
slow and reverse aging | |||
from the world expert | |||
himself, Dr David Sinclair. | |||
And last, but certainly not least, | |||
thank you for your interest in science. | |||
[upbeat music] |